Sulis Al Arif

Institute for Research and Community Service (LP2M) of the State Islamic University, Salatiga

DOI : https://doi.org/10.58806/ijsshmr.2025.v4i1n07

Google Scholar Download Pdf
ABSTRACT

This research analyzes the effectiveness and efficiency of three methods of lecturer and employee attendance used at the State Islamic University (UIN) Salatiga, namely: Squadron Android application, Smart Staff Android and iOS applications, and Fingerprint. This research uses a comparative quantitative approach with data collected through questionnaires from 76 respondents. The results of the research indicate that the Squadron Android application method has the highest level of satisfaction, accuracy, and socialization compared to other methods. However, all methods still face technical constraints, such as tool sensitivity and limited reach. This research recommends technical improvements, increased functionality, and integration of attendance systems to improve user experience. The Squadron Android application attendance method shows a higher value than Smart Staff Android and iOS applications and Fingerprint. Many respondents considered the ease of use and accuracy of the Squadron Android application attendance method better than other attendance methods.

KEYWORDS:

Attendance, Effectiveness, Efficiency, Technology

REFERENCES

1) Amin, NF, Garancang, S., & Abunawas, K. (2023). General concepts of population and sample in research. Pillar , 14 (1), 15–31.

2) ARDIANTO, S. (2022). Lecturer Attendance System Based on Mobile Application of Sultan Agung Waqf Foundation Using Geolocation.

3) Ardianto, S., Subroto, IMI, & Haviana, SFC (2023). College Employee Attendance Based on Mobile Application Using Geolocation and Biometric Verification. TRANSISTOR Electrical and Informatics , 4 (3), 181–189.

4) Azis, N., Pribadi, G., & Nurcahya, MS (2020). Analysis and Design of Android-Based Basic English Learning Application. IKRA-ITH INFORMATIKA: Journal of Computers and Informatics , 4 (3), 1–5.

5) Badruddin, S. (2014). Effectiveness of Finger Print Implementation at IAIN Raden Fatah Palembang. Wardah , 15 (1), 33–34.

6) Budiastuti, D. (2022). Validity and reliability of research .

7) Darma, B. (2021). Research Statistics Using SPSS (Validity Test, Reliability Test, Simple Linear Regression, Multiple Linear Regression, t-Test, F-Test, R2) . Guepedia.

8) Darussalam, U., & Natashia, ND (2020). Fingerprint Attendance System Based on Android Smartphone. JIMP-Journal of Informatics Merdeka Pasuruan , 5 (1).

9) Effendy, I., & Bakti, AM (2019). Smart Attendance Integration for Lecturers as an Effort to Improve Performance. Klik-Kumpulan J. Comput Science , 6 (3), 317–326.

10) Fansury, AH, Rahman, MA, & Jabu, B. (2021). Developing mobile English application as teaching media: Developing English language applications as learning media . Deepublish.

11) Gumelar, W. (2019). Lecturer and Staff Attendance System Using GPS Based on Mobile Device Fingerprint .

12) Gunawan, R., Yusuf, AM, & Nopitasari, L. (2021). Design and Construction of Student Attendance System Using Android-Based Qr Code. Elkom: Journal of Electronics and Computers , 14 (1), 47–58.

13) Hamdani, D., Wibowo, APW, & Heryono, H. (2024). Design of Online Attendance System with QR Code Using Prototyping Method. Journal of Technology and Information , 14 (1), 62–73.

14) Harmoko, MP, Kilwalaga, I., Pd, SPI, Asnah, S., Rahmi, S., Adoe, VS, SP, M., Dyanasari, I., & Arina, F. (2022). Research methodology textbook . Feniks Muda Sejahtera.

15) Hastono, SP (2001). Data analysis. Depok: Faculty of Public Health, University of Indonesia , 1–2.

16) Hernawan, D., & Pratidina, G. (2024). Effectiveness of Implementing Online Attendance for ASN Employees on the Super Apps Smart Staff Application (Case Study: Bogor Regency Ministry of Religion Office). Karimah Tauhid , 3 (4), 3990–4003.

17) Jailani, MS (2023). Data collection techniques and instruments for scientific educational research using qualitative and quantitative approaches. IHSAN: Journal of Islamic Education , 1 (2), 1–9.

18) Janna, NM, & Herianto, H. (2021). The concept of validity and reliability testing using SPSS .

19) Johan, TM (2021). Lecturer Attendance System Using RFID to Support Less Contact-Based Higher Education Administration During the Covid-19 Pandemic. Tika Journal , 6 (03), 270–276.

20) Kusuma, IWWN, Putra, IGJE, & Nirmala, BPW (2021). GuideAR: An Augmented Reality and Global Positioning System-Based Application for Tourist Attraction Recognition. KARMAPATI (Collection of Articles by Informatics Engineering Education Students) , 10 (1), 78–87.

21) Labolo, I. (2019). Implementation of QRCode for Student Lecture Attendance Based on Paperless Office. Upgris Informatics Journal , 5 (1).

22) Magriyanti, AA, & Mustofa, Z. (2020). Implementation of Student Attendance Information System Using Fingerprint Integrated with SMS Gateway. Journal of Information and Communication Technology , 11 (1), 56–66.

23) Maulidya, NP, Larassaty, AL, & Pujianto, WE (2021). The Effect of Implementation of Fingerprint Attendance, Sanctions, and Motivation on Employee Work Discipline at Intako. Greenomika , 3 (2), 88–96.

24) Meyliana-UBSI, A. (2020). Design of Employee Attendance Information System with Prototype Method Using Fingerprint. SPEED-Sentra Penelitian Engineering Dan Edukasi , 12 (2).

25) Novikasari, I. (2016). Instrument Validity Test. Purwokerto: State Islamic Institute of Purwokerto , 56 .

26) Nuantra, VA, Sacky, MR, Kristianto, W., Fadillah, MR, Mahmudah, MJ, Hanif, SAC, & Yuamita, F. (2022). Usability Testing Factors for the Use of Attendance on the SIA UTY Website. Journal of Applied Industrial Technology and Management , 1 (3), 173–182.

27) Nugraha, AK, Satoto, KI, & Kridalukmana, R. (2014). Design of Bubble Letter Game (Wayang Character) Based on iOS Operating System Using Gamesalad. Journal of Computer Technology and Systems , 2 (1), 1–10.

28) Octaviani, R., & Sutriani, E. (2019). Data analysis and data validity checking .

29) PRAYOGA, DP, & Nalien, EM (2023). Factors Influencing the Success of Implementing the Use of Online Presence. Minangkabau Government Applied Journal , 3 (1), 18–27.

30) Priyambodo, A., Usman, K., & Novamizanti, L. (2020). Implementation of Android-Based QR Code in Attendance System. J. Technol. Inf. And Comput Science , 7 (5).

31) Putra, YWS, & Adhim, MF (2022). Online Attendance Information System Using Face Recognition and GPS Technology. Jurnal Tekno Kompak , 16 (1), 149–161.

32) Rachman, A., Dunggio, T., & Rachman, AA (2023). The Influence of Discipline on Employee Performance. Bisnisman Journal: Business and Management Research , 5 (1), 143–151.

33) Rafai, M., Solikhun, S., & Safii, M. (2024). Design of Website-Based Student QR Code Attendance at Stikom Tunas Bangsa Pematang Siantar Using Agile Method. Jayakarta Informatics Management Journal , 4 (1), 51–60.

34) Rahmawati, SR, & Purwadhi, P. (2020). The Influence of the Effectiveness of Fingerprint Attendance and Incentive Implementation on FPOK UPI Employee Discipline. Service Management Triangle: Journal of Service Management , 2 (1).

35) Riyanti, AS, Pramono, J., & Sugiyarti, SR (2023). The effectiveness of the implementation of the presence system in employee work discipline within the Klaten Regency Personnel and Human Resources Development Agency. Solidaritas: Journal of Social Sciences , 7 (2).

36) Roedyanto, MC, Andjarwirawan, J., & Noertjahyana, A. (2019). Mobile Application for the Attendance System of Lecturers and Employees of Petra Christian University. Infra Journal , 7 (1), 102–107.

37) Ruauw, G., Tumbel, GH, Kawahe, M., & Lumingkewas, E. (2023). Implementation of Electronic-Based Attendance. Scientific Journal of Regional Government Administration , 15 (2), 237–249.

38) Sahir, SH (2021). Research methodology . KBM Indonesia Publisher.

39) Saied, M., & Syafii, A. (2023). Design and Implementation of the Latest Technology-Based Attendance System to Improve the Efficiency of Employee Attendance Management in Companies. Indonesian Engineering Journal , 2 (3), 87–92.

40) Saputra, R., & Fadtha, TSE (2014). Islamic Daily Prayer Application on Android Operating System. Science and Information Technology , 3 (1), 80–84.

41) Semi, H. (2024). Implementation of Fingerprint Technology in Improving Teacher Discipline. Kelola: Journal of Islamic Education Management , 9 (1), 1–11.

42) Sihotang, YS, Sitanggang, MSH, Purba, M., & Tarigan, LL (2024). The Role of Online Attendance Effectiveness in Supporting Employee Performance at the Regional Office of the Directorate General of Treasury, General Affairs, North Sumatra Province. Skylandsea Professional Journal of Economics, Business and Technology , 4 (1), 35–41.

43) Sinurat, EA, Siahaan, YD, Saribu, AD, Pardosi, RW, Manurung, V., Ompusunggu, JP, Saragi, KS, Zai, PF, & Silitonga, CEJ (2024). UTILIZATION OF MARKETING COSTS TO IMPROVE EFFICIENCY, EFFECTIVENESS AND PRODUCTIVITY BASED ON DEA. Competitive Accounting Journal , 7 (2), 204–212.

44) Steers, R. M. (1976). When is an organization effective? A process approach to understanding effectiveness. Organizational Dynamics , 5 (2), 50–63.

45) Sunarya, PA, Febriyanto, E., & Januarini, J. (2019). Mobile Application for Employee Attendance and Leave Submission Based on GPS. CCIT Journal , 12 (2), 241–247.

46) Veren, S., Sari, RP, & Febriyanto, F. (2023). Web-Based Online Attendance System for Employees and Lecturers. Journal of Information Systems and Technology , 33–40.

47) Vivi Silvia, S. (2020). Descriptive Statistics . Andi Publisher.

48) Wijaya, SW, & Firdaus, M. (2023). Design and Construction of an Online Attendance Application Information System with an Agnostic Platform . 2 (1), 795–809.

VOlUME 04 ISSUE 01 JANUARY 2025